In 1960, a team at the University of Illinois released the first version of their PLATO “computerized instruction system,” a network of what would eventually be thousands of computer terminals connected to large mainframe computers.
The "possibly" in your manufacturing explanation seems important. More investment could improve yields, but better early yields could also attract more investment. Those paths can reinforce each other while implying different lessons for the next technology.
Would a timeline of factory investment and yield improvements help distinguish which advantage came first? That would make the business lesson more useful than treating manufacturing scale as a verdict after the winner is known.
“Plasma had some advantages over LCD TVs — they could offer richer colors and higher refresh rates — but also some disadvantages.”
An additional advantage is higher contrast ratio (deeper blacks). I think a huge effort has gone into LCD development to improve real and perceived black levels. One disadvantage: I believe that plasma displays are significantly heavier than LCDs.
The one thing I distinctly remember about the book “The Friendly Orange Glow: The Untold Story of the PLATO System and the Dawn of Cyberculture”
Is that “ Leonard nimoy famously admitted that neither he nor co-star William Shatner actually knew the rules of the complex 3-D chess game they played on Star Trek.” (I think the book even mentions that nimoy didn’t even like chess. Period)
Thanks for this. I read the popular history book on PLATO when it came out 8 or 9 years ago... http://friendlyorangeglow.com/ . I think often about it, in particular as the homebrew 'cybereck' scene has expanded in recent years. The PLATO tech stack and vision was very impressive and worthy of study / emulation in todays age.
The useful detail is that the display was commissioned for a teaching terminal network that never reached the scale it was designed for. The technology outlived its justification by decades, then lost to a format whose factories had already been paid for by a different product. Which one wins is mostly a question of who else financed the capacity first. Performance arrives late to that decision.
The detail I can't shake is that the memory effect showed up because a little air accidentally got into the test cell. Years of careful engineering, and the breakthrough was a leak. (My kitchen has run on this principle for years; I just call it seasoning.) The part that surprised me more is how plasma lost: not by being a worse screen, but by being a worse thing to manufacture while LCD collected all the factory money. Technology graveyards must be full of products that were perfectly fine and simply unlucky in their factories.
Mind you, vacuum tubes aren't just used for audio these days: they're still used in high-power applications where transistors aren't adequate.
The "possibly" in your manufacturing explanation seems important. More investment could improve yields, but better early yields could also attract more investment. Those paths can reinforce each other while implying different lessons for the next technology.
Would a timeline of factory investment and yield improvements help distinguish which advantage came first? That would make the business lesson more useful than treating manufacturing scale as a verdict after the winner is known.
“Plasma had some advantages over LCD TVs — they could offer richer colors and higher refresh rates — but also some disadvantages.”
An additional advantage is higher contrast ratio (deeper blacks). I think a huge effort has gone into LCD development to improve real and perceived black levels. One disadvantage: I believe that plasma displays are significantly heavier than LCDs.
The one thing I distinctly remember about the book “The Friendly Orange Glow: The Untold Story of the PLATO System and the Dawn of Cyberculture”
Is that “ Leonard nimoy famously admitted that neither he nor co-star William Shatner actually knew the rules of the complex 3-D chess game they played on Star Trek.” (I think the book even mentions that nimoy didn’t even like chess. Period)
Thanks for this. I read the popular history book on PLATO when it came out 8 or 9 years ago... http://friendlyorangeglow.com/ . I think often about it, in particular as the homebrew 'cybereck' scene has expanded in recent years. The PLATO tech stack and vision was very impressive and worthy of study / emulation in todays age.
The useful detail is that the display was commissioned for a teaching terminal network that never reached the scale it was designed for. The technology outlived its justification by decades, then lost to a format whose factories had already been paid for by a different product. Which one wins is mostly a question of who else financed the capacity first. Performance arrives late to that decision.
The detail I can't shake is that the memory effect showed up because a little air accidentally got into the test cell. Years of careful engineering, and the breakthrough was a leak. (My kitchen has run on this principle for years; I just call it seasoning.) The part that surprised me more is how plasma lost: not by being a worse screen, but by being a worse thing to manufacture while LCD collected all the factory money. Technology graveyards must be full of products that were perfectly fine and simply unlucky in their factories.
Thanks, Claude.