4 Comments
User's avatar
Dave Stuhlsatz's avatar

I concur completely with Jim's comment on ResCheck and Comcheck. Narrowly defined, 2-dimensional software programs that deal with one aspect of building performance are also open to "gaming the system" with bad inputs. The human element in the building inspection process for energy conservation requires inspectors who are trained and motivated to be picky about insulation installation, air-sealing, etc...

On a related note, the Architectural Registration Exam graphic software is fully automated with respect to evaluating a candidate's "design" for code compliant building elements like egress, stair proportions, furniture placement. I believe the code for this dates to the 1980's. It's crude, but I'd argue that it's sufficient for drilling my profession into thinking about objective results; i.e. making sure a building has minimum life-safety parameters.

Scaling up ARE-like software to a BIM model would require standardization of software inputs and outputs. I suppose machine learning could be applied to the evaluation of floor plans in .pdf format. Where's the incentive in that?

Ajit's avatar

Thanks Brian, wonderfully written. Keep posting great content. Best Wishes from Australia.

Kurt's avatar

Many thanks, very interesting reading. The challenges highlighted could be applied to many other areas where digitization is tried, but turns out to be harder than it seems.

There is some activity from Google on this. For their own internal use, they created a Digital Buildings model language. More importantly, an Alphabet spinoff, Flux, tried to solve these issues in 2017–2020, before throwing in the towel, as noted here: https://parametricmonkey.com/2020/06/03/rediscovering-flux/ . As a story, it confirms the points you make in your article.

User's avatar
Comment deleted
May 28, 2022Edited
Comment deleted
Brian Potter's avatar

This is an interesting point I hadn't considered, thanks.