10 Comments

This is a great article on one of the most important technological innovations of the last 50 years.

Your conclusions are particularly strong. The old Silicon Valley mantra about “First Mover Advantage” is clearly not the rule. In fact, I would argue that it is the exception.

Plus the relationship between Basic Science and launching a viable product is much more complex than most people realize.

Expand full comment

I assume the subtext is the bankruptcy of Northvolt?

Expand full comment

Shows how bad capitalism is .things move by chance and luck

Expand full comment

It's the worst economic system, except for all the others.

Expand full comment

No.socialism is better

Expand full comment

This was brilliant. Just saw this tweet and you came to mind immediately. About innovation in single photon avalanche diodes making xray and radar more accessible https://x.com/sdamico/status/1863487947233972248?t=yBiSJsNUdjT0-nKyq7u5MA&s=19

Expand full comment

Portable power tools drove Li battery progress for 20 years. Consumer electronics mostly used NiMH which was much cheaper and had no safety issues. The few exceptions were small format. When EVs showed up they used power tool batteries, which was why it was Panasonic not Sony who moved forward.

You overlooked probably the most important part of the commercial story. If not for power tools, we would be far behind the curve on EVs and storage today.

Expand full comment

Learnt so much even after having spent years working with the tech. Excellent research!

Expand full comment

Great article, full of insight. It was a privilege to work with Michael Thackeray. If my recollection is correct, Dr Brian Clark, who became the President of the CSIR, granted him the sabbatical.

Expand full comment

Excellent and informative as always

Expand full comment